Insulin-Induced Hypoglycemia and Its Effect on the Brain: Unraveling Metabolism by In Vivo Nuclear Magnetic Resonance

Hypoglycemia, a frequent occurrence during modern intensive insulin therapy, remains the major limiting factor in achieving optimal glucose control in type 1 diabetic patients as well as in patients with long-standing type 2 diabetes. This has been a challenge for clinicians and investigators since several large population-based studies such as the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial and UK Prospective Diabetes Study established the long-term benefits of tight glycemic control many years ago (1,2). More recently, studies of intensive glucose control in patients with diabetes of several years duration have—to the surprise to many—been either terminated because of increased mortality in the intensive control arm or because worse outcomes were revealed in regard to the clinical end points (3,4). In a parallel development, we have gone, over the course of 10 years, from embracing stringent inpatient glucose control via insulin infusion protocols in the intensive care setting (5) to realizing that not everybody may benefit equally from such an intervention, since the increased incidence of profound hypoglycemia is the limiting factor (6). In fact, a recent systematic review of 21 trials of intensive insulin therapy by Kansagara et al. (7) found a sixfold higher risk of severe hypoglycemic events in patients undergoing such therapy. Faced with a clinical dilemma of such proportion, it appears that we may need to readdress our hypotheses, and we need to conduct mechanistic studies that allow us to identify therapies that are effective but minimize the exposure of patients to the heightened risk of hypoglycemia. Understanding the regulation of glucose metabolism in the brain and how it responds to hypoglycemia in this context is of particular relevance because of the brain’s exquisite dependence on glucose as an energy substrate and its integrative function in whole body fuel homeostasis (8).

The brain poses particular challenges because, due to limited glucose transport activity in the blood brain barrier and high rates of cellular glucose metabolism, the concentrations of glucose in human brain interstitial fluid are only about a fifth of those in plasma, making the brain highly vulnerable to a drop in glucose supply (9). Magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS), which allows monitoring of glucose and other substrate metabolism in vivo offers the unique opportunity to study glucose metabolism behind the blood brain barrier in real time. Using the stable ¹³C isotope as a tracer, labeled glucose or other substrates are infused and label appearance in the metabolite pools of glutamate and glutamine can be observed over time. Fitting of these data with a mathematical model of metabolism allows calculation of substrate-specific metabolism as well as compartmentation of metabolism between the two major brain cell types, neurons and glia (Fig. 1).

To test whether moderate hypoglycemia can reduce human brain energy production, van de Ven et al. (10) used ¹³C MRS to study glucose metabolism in healthy control subjects during euglycemia and hypoglycemia using a hyperinsulinemic clamp to maintain stable glycemia. Eight subjects served as their own controls and were studied at a glucose level of 5 mM and at 3 mM, thereby reducing the confounding influence of interindividual variability. Interestingly, the authors were not able to detect a difference between tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle activity under euglycemic and hypoglycemic conditions. They suggest that oxidative brain metabolism was not impaired in a way that would have resulted in decreased production of ATP further downstream, in seeming contradiction with results showing impaired cortical function in control subjects at similar levels of hypoglycemia (11,12).

There are several potential explanations for the paradoxical results of van de Ven et al. (10), including the brain region observed and a switch of cerebral metabolism to alternate substrates. An important point to keep in mind is that most current MRS studies are focused on the brain tissue most adjacent to the nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) coil, the occipital cortex. Because we know from animal studies and human positron emission tomography studies (13) that metabolic activity can vary substantially from region to region and change when local activity is stimulated (14), we must ask ourselves how the current observations can be applied from the occipital cortex to other areas of the brain. Several human studies using functional magnetic resonance imaging, which uses blood oxygen tension differences as a surrogate of regional activation, support the notion that changes in the activation patterns of the brain under acute hypoglycemia do occur (15,16). It is therefore likely that with the advent of more localized NMR spectroscopy we will be able to further delineate regional differences of metabolism.

We must also take into consideration that energy substrates other than glucose may increase their contribution to TCA cycle activity, which in the brain is composed of separate and cooperative glial and neuronal compartments. For a schematic representation of these changes, see Fig. 1. Astrocytes (a form of glial cell predominant in the cerebral cortex) have emerged as playing a potentially important role by temporarily supplying neurons with fuel derived from stored glycogen, which could provide extra substrate during a hypoglycemic period (17). A reduction of astrocytic glucose metabolism to spare glucose for the neuron is also possible, and changes in the balance between neuronal and astrocyte glucose oxidation in animal models during hypoglycemia have been reported by our group (18). An alternative possibility is that there was an increase in the metabolism of lactate derived from the circulation, which increased by 50% under hypoglycemia. It has been reported that an infusion of lactate given to subjects during a comparable clamp study was able to alleviate cognitive dysfunction (19). We note that based on MRS measurements of glucose transport activity (20,21), the reduction in net glucose transport at 3 mmol/L plasma glucose levels would reduce glucose uptake on the order of 5–10%. Although van de Ven et al. indirectly calculate an up to 5% contribution of lactate, direct measurement of lactate metabolism by ¹³C MRS (22) as well as arteriovenous difference methods (23) suggest that at the lactate levels achieved in the hypoglycemia portion of the study by van de Ven et al. the contribution of lactate oxidation is most likely greater and can support close to 10% of neuronal metabolic needs.

A more comprehensive understanding of the adaptations of brain fuel metabolism to acute and recurrent hypoglycemia will likely serve as the foundation for the development of more specific therapeutic interventions that avert the negative impact of neuroglycopenia in patients receiving insulin therapy.